Tags
In his wonderful book of 1987, The Closing of the American Mind, Allan Bloom put forward a memorable argument about America’s intellectual elite. They wanted to be champions of a liberal arts education, and therefore embraced modern values, consumer culture and a soggy relativism; but in this flight from the classics and tradition, they had - as the book’s subtitle put it - “failed democracy and impoverished the souls of today’s students”. A paradox, then: in opening their imaginations, they had closed their minds. |
A similar but infinitely more alarming process is under way in the world’s greatest democracy. Last week, Penguin India, an arm of Penguin Random House, agreed to destroy all unsold copies in India of The Hindus: An Alternative History by the University of Chicago professor Wendy Doniger.
This came as part of a court-supervised settlement in a legal case against Penguin by a bunch of cowards called Shiksha Andolan Bachao, or the Save Education Movement.
An excellent analysis for the Financial Times by Amy Kazmin showed how this censorship has spread like a plague across India. In 2004, the authorities banned a history of Shivaji, a 17th-century king, after Hindu bigots attacked the library in which its author consulted manuscripts. Two years later, Maqbool Fida Husain, perhaps India’s greatest living artist, was forced into exile because his works, which sometimes depicted Hindu deities naked, were vandalised.
Just this January, a book about Air India was withdrawn, and Bloomsbury apologised after a former aviation minister got twitchy about its contents; and the High Court in Calcutta suppressed a book about a real-estate conglomerate, while fearing reprisal.
There are countless more examples. What unites them is a pattern of Hindu extremist aggression meeting with success. This is urgent and desperately sad. Urgent, because in May Narendra Modi, the highly competent chief minister of Gujarat who specialises in insulting Muslims, will probably be elected the country’s leader, much to the pleasure of those extremists. And desperately sad because of what India is.
When Jawaharlal Nehru spoke of the “tryst with destiny” that marked the birth of this nation, he emphasised pluralism and tolerance. The Constitution declared India a sovereign, socialist, secular, democratic republic. With regular failings, India has strived to meet Karl Popper’s vision of an open society, with nearly as many Muslims as Pakistan and Christians as Australia, and a crazy experiment in democracy that gave 788mn people the right to vote.
But the spirit of Nehru and his fellow founding fathers has faded. India is now engaged in its own culture wars, and the good guys aren’t winning. The great divide among nations today isn’t so much ideological as between those that are open or closed in the face of globalisation.
And for those of us who savour its intellectual heritage, the closing of the Indian mind is a catastrophe. In fact, it’s beginning to feel like we’ve got three months to save the spirit of a great nation.- London Evening Standard
♦ Amol Rajan is the editor of The Independent newspaper in London. Twitter.com/amolrajan
There are no comments.
Saying goodbye is never easy, especially when you are saying farewell to those that have left a positive impression. That was the case earlier this month when Canada hosted Mexico in a friendly at BC Place stadium in Vancouver.
Some 60mn primary-school-age children have no access to formal education
Lekhwiya’s El Arabi scores the equaliser after Tresor is sent off; Tabata, al-Harazi score for QSL champions
The Yemeni Minister of Tourism, Dr Mohamed Abdul Majid Qubati, yesterday expressed hope that the 48-hour ceasefire in Yemen declared by the Command of Coalition Forces on Saturday will be maintained in order to lift the siege imposed on Taz City and ease the entry of humanitarian aid to the besieged
Some 200 teachers from schools across the country attended Qatar Museum’s (QM) first ever Teachers Council at the Museum of Islamic Art (MIA) yesterday.
The Supreme Judiciary Council (SJC) of Qatar and the Indonesian Supreme Court (SCI) have signed a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) on judicial co-operation, it was announced yesterday.
Sri Lanka is keen on importing liquefied natural gas (LNG) from Qatar as part of government policy to shift to clean energy, Minister of City Planning and Water Supply Rauff Hakeem has said.